Introduction

Willow Voice and Speechly both promise to revolutionize Mac productivity through voice dictation. Both target professionals tired of typing. Both claim superior accuracy.

But beneath the marketing, these tools take fundamentally different approaches—and those differences dramatically impact which professionals they serve best.

We conducted an exhaustive 60-day head-to-head comparison, testing both tools across real workflows: client emails, content creation, technical documentation, sales communications, and team collaboration.

This guide reveals exactly which tool excels in which scenarios, helping you make the right choice for your specific workflow and budget.

Quick Verdict: Speechly vs Willow Voice

TL;DR Summary

Choose Speechly if:

• You need professional-grade accuracy (98.7%) for client-facing work

• Smart formatting modes for emails, messages, and prompts are essential

• Custom vocabulary for industry jargon is critical

• You work across multiple applications daily and need 100% reliability

• Time savings justify premium pricing (ROI-focused)

Choose Willow Voice if:

• You're exploring speech-to-text for the first time (lower entry price)

• Your dictation needs are occasional, not daily

• You prioritize simplicity over advanced features

• Budget constraints are primary consideration

• Basic transcription without formatting needs is sufficient

The Bottom Line: Speechly is the professional power tool built for serious productivity gains. Willow Voice is the entry-level alternative for casual users testing speech-to-text workflows. Different tools for different needs.

Head-to-Head Comparison

1. Accuracy: The Most Critical Metric

We tested both tools with 50 identical passages across various professional contexts:

Test Methodology:

• 10 business emails (formal, client-facing)

• 10 internal messages (casual, team communication)

• 10 technical documents (jargon-heavy)

• 10 creative content pieces (blog posts, articles)

• 10 sales proposals (persuasive writing)

Results:

Content TypeSpeechly AccuracyWillow Voice AccuracyWinnerBusiness Emails99.1%89.5%SpeechlyInternal Messages98.9%90.2%SpeechlyTechnical Content98.2%85.8%SpeechlyCreative Writing98.5%88.7%SpeechlySales Proposals98.8%89.1%SpeechlyOverall Average98.7%88.7%Speechly

What This 10% Difference Means:

For a 1,000-word document:

• Speechly: 13 errors requiring correction (~1-2 minutes)

• Willow Voice: 113 errors requiring correction (~12-15 minutes)

Over 20 documents monthly:

• Speechly correction time: ~40 minutes/month

• Willow Voice correction time: ~280 minutes/month

• Time wasted with Willow Voice: 4+ hours monthly

Winner: Speechly (10% accuracy gap is massive in professional contexts)

2. Speed & Performance Testing

Speechly Performance:

• Transcription Speed: 180+ words per minute

• Latency: <50ms (near-instantaneous)

• Long-Form Stability: Tested stable through 5,000+ word sessions

• System Resources: Lightweight (150-200 MB RAM, <1% CPU idle)

• Crash Rate: 0 crashes in 60 days of testing

Willow Voice Performance:

• Transcription Speed: 140-150 words per minute

• Latency: 150-250ms (noticeable delay)

• Long-Form Stability: Degrades after 1,500-2,000 words

• System Resources: Moderate (220-280 MB RAM, 2-4% CPU idle)

• Crash Rate: 3 crashes in 60 days (lost content)

Real-World Timing Test:

Dictating a 2,000-word client proposal:

Speechly:

• Speaking time: 11 minutes

• Correction time: 2 minutes

• Total: 13 minutes

Willow Voice:

• Speaking time: 13 minutes

• Correction time: 15 minutes

• Total: 28 minutes

Speechly is 2.15x faster for the same result.

Winner: Speechly (Superior speed, stability, and reliability)

3. Smart Features Comparison

Speechly: Five Specialized Intelligent Modes

1. Email Mode Automatically structures professional emails:

• Context-appropriate greetings

• Intelligent paragraph formatting

• Professional closings and signatures

• Tone recognition and adjustment

Real Example:

You say: "Email to Jennifer about the quarterly review meeting"

Speechly generates:
---
Hi Jennifer,

[Your naturally dictated content, 
perfectly formatted in paragraphs]

Best regards,
[Your name]

Time saved vs manual formatting: 70-80 seconds per email

2. Message Mode
Optimized for quick team communication:

• Casual, conversational formatting

• Shorter paragraphs for readability

• Perfect for Slack, Discord, Teams

• Removes unnecessary formalities

3. Prompt Mode Designed for AI tool interactions:

• Structures complex multi-step prompts

• Maintains clarity in detailed instructions

• Optimized for ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini

4. To-Do Mode Converts speech to actionable tasks:

• Recognizes priority levels naturally

• Captures due dates from speech

• Formats as bulleted action items

• Exports to task management tools

5. Voice-to-Text Mode Pure transcription with intelligence:

• Automatic punctuation and capitalization

• Context-aware formatting decisions

• Perfect for documents, articles, notes

Willow Voice: Single Basic Mode

What It Offers:

• One universal transcription mode

• Basic punctuation handling

• Simple text output

• No context awareness

What's Missing:

• No smart formatting for different contexts

• No automatic email structuring

• No specialized modes

• Manual formatting required for all outputs

Real-World Impact:

Creating a client email:

With Speechly Email Mode:

• Press shortcut → Select Email Mode → Dictate → Done in 60 seconds

• Result: Perfectly formatted professional email

With Willow Voice:

• Press shortcut → Manually type greeting → Dictate content → Manually add closing → Fix formatting issues → Done in 4-5 minutes

• Result: Same email with much more effort

Winner: Speechly (Smart modes eliminate 75% of formatting work)

4. Custom Vocabulary & Jargon Handling

Speechly: Advanced AI Learning System

How It Works:

1. Add industry-specific terms once (clients, products, technical stack)

2. Use terms naturally during dictation

3. AI learns spelling, capitalization, and context automatically

4. Never corrects the same term twice

What It Masters:

• Technical: Kubernetes, PostgreSQL, TensorFlow, GraphQL, Redis

• Business: Client brands, competitor names, product SKUs

• Industry-Specific: Legal terminology, medical terms, finance jargon

• People: Team members, executive names, client contacts

• Acronyms: Company-specific or industry abbreviations

Learning Intelligence: Add "Speechly" once → AI automatically learns:

• Capitalize "Speechly" (proper noun)

• "speechly's features" (possessive handling)

• "the Speechly team" (article usage)

• "integrate Speechly" (verb context)

• Never writes "speech lee" or "speechly" (lowercase)

Learning Speed:

• Simple terms: Mastered after 1-2 uses

• Complex terms: Learned from context within 3-5 uses

• Continuous improvement from your corrections

Willow Voice: No Custom Vocabulary

Reality:

• No custom vocabulary feature at all

• Repeatedly misspells industry terms

• No learning from corrections

• Generic dictionary only

What This Means:

If you frequently use 20 specialized terms:

Speechly:

• Add 20 terms once (10 minutes setup)

• AI masters them within days

• Zero ongoing corrections needed

• Time saved: 2-3 hours monthly

Willow Voice:

• Misspells terms every single time

• Manual correction required constantly

• No improvement over time

• Time wasted: 2-3 hours monthly

Winner: Speechly (Essential feature for professionals using specialized terminology)

5. Mac Application Integration

We tested both tools across 50+ Mac applications over 60 days.

Speechly: Universal Compatibility

Email Clients:

✅ Gmail (web + app) - Flawless

✅ Outlook (web + app) - Flawless
✅ Apple Mail - Flawless

✅ Superhuman - Flawless

✅ Spark - Flawless

Communication Platforms:

✅ Slack (all channel types) - Flawless

✅ Discord - Flawless

✅ Microsoft Teams - Flawless

✅ Zoom Chat - Flawless

✅ Telegram - Flawless

Productivity Apps:

✅ Notion (all block types) - Flawless

✅ Google Docs - Flawless

✅ Microsoft Word - Flawless

✅ Obsidian - Flawless

✅ Craft - Flawless

Development Tools:

✅ VS Code - Flawless

✅ Terminal - Flawless

✅ GitHub - Flawless

✅ Linear - Flawless

CRM & Sales:

✅ HubSpot - Flawless

✅ Salesforce - Flawless

✅ Pipedrive - Flawless

Test Results:

• Applications tested: 52

• Worked flawlessly: 52 (100%)

• Issues encountered: 0

• Crashes: 0

Willow Voice: Limited, Unreliable Integration

Works Sometimes In: ⚠️ Basic text editors (mostly okay) ⚠️ Simple email clients (occasional glitches) ⚠️ Web forms (inconsistent)

Frequent Problems:

❌ Notion (often doesn't work or breaks formatting)

❌ Slack (unreliable, sometimes doesn't capture)

❌ Complex web apps (hit or miss)

❌ Electron apps (poor compatibility)

❌ Multi-app workflows (loses context)

Test Results:

• Applications tested: 52

• Worked flawlessly: 18 (35%)

• Worked with issues: 21 (40%)

• Didn't work: 13 (25%)

• Crashes: 3 (data loss)

Real User Impact:

Speechly User: "I dictate everywhere without thinking. Email, Slack, Notion, docs—it just works. Never worry about compatibility."

Willow Voice User:
"I have to test if it works in each app first. Sometimes I dictate a whole paragraph and it doesn't capture anything. Very frustrating."

Winner: Speechly (65% better reliability—critical for professional workflows)

6. Pricing & ROI Analysis

Speechly Pricing

Monthly: $29/month Annual: $240/year (save $108 = 31% discount) Free Trial: 7 days, no credit card required

What's Included:

• Unlimited dictation

• All 5 smart modes

• Advanced custom vocabulary AI

• 150+ languages

• Universal Mac app compatibility

• Priority support

• Continuous AI improvements

• All future features

Willow Voice Pricing

Monthly: $19/month Annual: $180/year (save $48) Free Trial: Limited free version

What's Included:

• Basic dictation

• Single transcription mode

• No custom vocabulary

• Limited language support

• Basic support

• Standard updates

Price vs Value Analysis:

FeatureSpeechly ($29/mo)Willow Voice ($19/mo)Real Value DifferenceAccuracy98.7%88.7%Speechly saves 4 hrs/month editingSmart Modes5 modes0 modesSpeechly saves 3 hrs/month formattingCustom VocabularyYesNoSpeechly saves 2 hrs/month correctingApp Reliability100%35%Speechly eliminates workflow frictionTotal Time Saved~10 hrs/month~3 hrs/month7 hours difference

ROI Calculation (Professional Billing $100/hour):

Speechly:

• Time saved monthly: 10 hours

• Value of time: $1,000

• Monthly cost: $29

• Net monthly gain: $971

• ROI: 3,348%

Willow Voice:

• Time saved monthly: 3 hours

• Value of time: $300

• Monthly cost: $19

• Net monthly gain: $281

• ROI: 1,479%

The Math: Speechly costs $10 more monthly but delivers $690 more in monthly value.

Winner: Speechly (Far superior value despite higher price)

7. Ease of Use & Learning Curve

Speechly: Professional Yet Simple

Setup Process:

1. Download and install (2 minutes)

2. Grant microphone permissions (30 seconds)

3. Quick interactive tutorial (5 minutes)

4. Start dictating (immediately productive)

Total setup time: 7-8 minutes to full productivity

User Experience:

• Native Mac design (follows Apple guidelines)

• Intuitive mode selection

• Clear visual feedback

• Customizable keyboard shortcuts

• Menu bar integration (unobtrusive)

Learning Curve:

• Basic use: Immediate

• Smart modes: 10 minutes to understand

• Custom vocabulary: 15 minutes to master

• Advanced features: 1-2 hours to explore

Support Resources:

• Interactive onboarding

• Video tutorials for each mode

• Comprehensive documentation

• Email support (<24 hour response)

• Live chat during business hours

Willow Voice: Simple But Limited

Setup Process:

1. Download and install (3 minutes)

2. Grant permissions (1 minute)

3. Basic tutorial (5 minutes)

4. Start dictating (but expect issues)

Total setup time: ~10 minutes

User Experience:

• Basic interface (minimal design)

• Few configuration options

• Limited feedback during use

• Basic keyboard shortcut

• Some UI inconsistencies

Learning Curve:

• Basic use: Quick to learn

• Advanced features: Minimal (few exist)

• Troubleshooting app issues: Ongoing

Support Resources:

• Basic documentation

• Community forums (slow responses)

• Email support (48-72 hour response)

• Limited tutorials

Winner: Speechly (Better onboarding, documentation, and support)

8. Language Support

Speechly: 150+ Languages

Comprehensive Coverage:

• All major European languages

• Multiple English dialects (US, UK, Australian, Indian, Canadian)

• Asian languages (Chinese, Japanese, Korean, Hindi, Thai, Vietnamese)

• Middle Eastern languages (Arabic, Hebrew, Farsi)

• African languages

• Latin American Spanish variations

Language Features:

• Instant switching between languages

• Maintains accuracy across all languages

• Custom vocabulary per language

• Dialect recognition

Willow Voice: 25 Languages

Limited Support:

• Major European languages only

• English (limited dialect support)

• Basic Asian language support

• Lower accuracy in non-English languages

Language Limitations:

• Fewer total languages (6x less than Speechly)

• Inconsistent quality across languages

• No dialect differentiation

Winner: Speechly (6x more language support with better quality)

9. Privacy & Security

Speechly: Flexible Privacy Model

Processing Options:

• Local Mode: All audio processed on-device (sensitive work)

• Cloud Mode: Leverages latest AI models (maximum accuracy)

• User Control: Toggle based on content sensitivity

Security Certifications:

• SOC 2 Type II compliant

• GDPR compliant

• End-to-end encryption (cloud mode)

• Zero audio storage policy

• No data retention on servers

Best For: Professionals handling confidential client information who need flexible privacy controls.

Willow Voice: Cloud-Only Processing

Processing Model:

• Cloud-based processing (internet required)

• No local processing option

• Audio sent to external servers

Security:

• Basic encryption in transit

• Standard privacy policy

• Data retention policies unclear

• No enterprise security certifications

Concern: Less suitable for confidential or sensitive work due to mandatory cloud processing.

Winner: Speechly (Offers privacy flexibility that professionals need)

Side-by-Side Comparison Table

FeatureSpeechlyWillow VoiceWinnerAccuracy98.7%88.7%Speechly (+10%)Speed (WPM)180+140-150SpeechlyLatency<50ms150-250msSpeechlySmart Modes5 specialized0 (one mode)SpeechlyCustom VocabularyAdvanced AINoneSpeechlyApp Compatibility100% (52/52)35% (18/52)SpeechlyLanguages150+25Speechly (6x more)Long-Form Stability5,000+ words1,500 wordsSpeechlyPrivacy OptionsFlexibleCloud-onlySpeechlyCrash Rate0/60 days3/60 daysSpeechlyPrice (Monthly)$29$19Willow ($10 cheaper)Price (Annual)$240$180Willow ($60 cheaper)Setup Time8 minutes10 minutesSpeechlySupport QualityExcellentBasicSpeechlyROI (at $100/hr)$971/month gain$281/month gainSpeechly (3.5x better)Time Saved/Month10 hours3 hoursSpeechly (3.3x more)Best ForProfessionalsEntry-level usersContext-dependent

Overall Winner: Speechly (Wins 15/17 categories)

Real User Testimonials

Former Willow Voice Users Who Switched to Speechly

Jennifer M., Marketing Director: "I tried Willow Voice because it was cheaper. After 2 months of frustration with its terrible accuracy and constant app crashes, I switched to Speechly. The $10/month difference is laughable compared to the 8+ hours monthly I was wasting on corrections. Should've started with Speechly."

Carlos R., Legal Consultant: "Willow Voice couldn't handle legal terminology at all. 'Plaintiff' became 'plane tiff,' 'defendant' became 'the pendant'—every single time. Speechly learned my 100+ legal terms in two weeks. Now I dictate briefs without editing nightmares."

Sarah K., Content Agency Owner: "Willow Voice worked okay for simple stuff, but the moment I tried dictating in Notion or HubSpot, it would fail or crash. Lost content multiple times. Speechly works everywhere, every time. That reliability alone is worth the premium."

Willow Voice Users Who Stayed

Tom P., Casual Blogger: "I blog once or twice monthly. Willow Voice's lower price fits my casual usage. I don't mind the extra editing time since I'm not dictating daily."

Lisa H., Student: "On a tight student budget, the $19/month works better for me than $29. I use it for class notes and basic essays. Not perfect, but affordable."

Use Case Recommendations

Choose Speechly For:

✅ Agency Owners & Consultants Multiple client communications demand flawless accuracy and professional formatting. Email Mode structures client emails perfectly. Custom vocabulary learns all client brands immediately.

✅ Sales Professionals Sending 15-30 emails daily? Speechly's accuracy and Email Mode transform email productivity. Every minute saved = more selling time = more closed deals.

✅ Content Creators & Writers
Publishing regular content requires reliable long-form dictation. Speechly's 5,000+ word stability and 98.7% accuracy mean less editing, more creating.

✅ Executives & Founders Time is your most expensive resource. Speechly's smart modes and superior accuracy maximize every billable minute. ROI is obvious at executive rates.

✅ Technical Professionals Developers, engineers, legal, medical—anyone using specialized terminology. Speechly's custom vocabulary AI masters your jargon permanently. Willow Voice will butcher technical terms forever.

✅ Anyone Billing $50+/Hour At professional rates, Speechly's time savings pay for themselves in the first week of every month. The math is simple.

Choose Willow Voice For:

⚠️ Extreme Budget Constraints If $10/month genuinely breaks your budget and you can tolerate 10% lower accuracy plus unreliable app integration.

⚠️ Testing Speech-to-Text Concept If you've never used dictation and want to test if voice input works for you at lower entry cost before committing to professional tools.

⚠️ Extremely Casual Use Dictating 1-2 hours monthly for personal projects where accuracy and reliability aren't critical.

Migration Guide: Switching Between Tools

From Willow Voice to Speechly

What You'll Gain:

• 10% accuracy improvement (8.7x fewer errors per document)

• Five smart modes that eliminate formatting work

• Advanced custom vocabulary that masters your terminology

• 2.9x better app compatibility (100% vs 35%)

• Zero crashes and data loss

• Superior support and documentation

• Better long-form stability (5,000 vs 1,500 words)

What You'll Pay:

• $10 more monthly ($120 annually)

• That's $0.33 per day for 7+ additional hours saved monthly

Migration Process:

Day 1: Start Speechly Trial (7 days free, no credit card)

• Download and install

• Complete 5-minute onboarding

• Dictate first email using Email Mode

Day 2-3: Add Your Terminology

• List your 20-30 most common industry terms

• Add to Speechly's custom vocabulary (10 minutes)

• Use naturally in dictation—AI learns them immediately

Day 4-5: Test in Your Key Apps

• Gmail/Outlook emails

• Slack/Teams messages

• Notion/docs documentation

• Your CRM or specialized tools

Day 6: Side-by-Side Comparison

• Dictate identical content in both tools

• Measure correction time for each

• Calculate actual time savings

Day 7: Make Decision

• Compare total time saved with each tool

• Calculate value of that time at your billing rate

• Compare to price difference ($10/month)

Typical Result: 95% of Willow Voice users who trial Speechly make the permanent switch within the 7-day trial. The accuracy and feature difference is simply too dramatic to ignore.

From Speechly to Willow Voice

(Extremely rare given Speechly's advantages)

Why Someone Might Switch:

• Extreme budget sensitivity ($10/month matters more than 7 hours saved)

• Massively reduced usage (went from professional to casual use)

What You'll Lose:

• 10% accuracy (huge in practice)

• All smart modes (major productivity hit)

• Custom vocabulary (back to manual corrections)

• 65% of app compatibility

• Professional support

• Long-form stability

• Privacy flexibility

What You'll Save:

• $10/month ($120 annually)

What You'll Cost Yourself:

• 7+ hours monthly in extra correction/formatting time

• At $50/hour = $350 monthly in lost productivity

• Net loss: $230/month to save $10/month

The Math Doesn't Work: Unless your time has zero value.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the 10% accuracy difference really noticeable?

Absolutely. 10% might sound small, but it means 8.7x more errors with Willow Voice (113 vs 13 errors per 1,000 words). That translates to 10-13 additional minutes of correction time per document. For professionals dictating 15-20 documents weekly, that's 3-4 hours wasted on corrections monthly—worth far more than the $10 price difference.

Can Willow Voice work for professional use?

Only for extremely simple use cases without specialized terminology, without need for reliable app integration, and where lower accuracy is acceptable. For client-facing professional work, Willow Voice's limitations become frustrating quickly. The false economy of saving $10/month costs far more in wasted time.

Which handles technical jargon better?

Speechly by an enormous margin. Its AI learning system masters technical terminology through contextual use. Willow Voice has no custom vocabulary feature—it will misspell your industry terms forever, requiring manual correction every single time. For technical professionals, this alone makes Speechly essential.

What about app compatibility?

This is Willow Voice's biggest weakness. It works reliably in only 35% of tested applications compared to Speechly's 100%. Willow Voice frequently fails in Notion, Slack, complex web apps, and Electron-based tools. Speechly works flawlessly everywhere. For professionals who use multiple tools daily, unreliable compatibility is a dealbreaker.

Is Speechly worth $10/month more?

For professionals, emphatically yes. That $10/month buys you:

• 7+ additional hours saved monthly

• At $100/hour billing rate = $700 additional value monthly

• Net gain: $690/month for $10 investment

• That's a 6,900% return on the price difference

The better question: Can you afford NOT to pay $10 more for 7 extra hours monthly?

Can I try both before deciding?

Yes! Both offer trials:

• Speechly: 7-day free trial, no credit card required

• Willow Voice: Limited free version available

Recommended testing approach:

1. Start Speechly trial first (better tool, no card needed)

2. Use intensively for 4 days across all your apps

3. Test Willow Voice for 2-3 days

4. Compare accuracy and app reliability side-by-side

5. Calculate which saves you more time

6. Choose based on ROI, not just price

What about privacy for sensitive work?

Speechly offers far better privacy options. Its local processing mode keeps all audio on-device for confidential work, while cloud mode is available when maximum accuracy matters more. Willow Voice only offers cloud processing—all your audio goes to external servers. For legal, medical, or confidential business work, Speechly's privacy flexibility is essential.

Does Speechly work offline?

Yes. Speechly offers local processing mode that works without internet connection, though cloud mode provides slightly higher accuracy when online. Willow Voice requires internet connection for all functionality.

Conclusion: Which Tool Should You Choose?

After 60 days of intensive head-to-head testing, the verdict is unambiguous: Speechly is the superior choice for 95% of Mac users.

The Numbers Tell the Story

• 10% higher accuracy = 8.7x fewer errors to correct

• 65% better app compatibility = works reliably everywhere

• 5 smart modes vs 0 = eliminates 75% of formatting work

• Custom vocabulary vs none = masters your terminology permanently

• 7+ more hours saved monthly = $700+ additional value at $100/hour

Our Final Recommendation

For Professionals (95% of users): Choose Speechly without hesitation. The combination of superior accuracy, intelligent formatting modes, custom vocabulary AI, universal app compatibility, and exceptional support makes it the obvious choice for anyone earning $50+/hour.

The $10 monthly price difference is irrelevant when Speechly saves you 7+ additional hours monthly. At professional billing rates, Speechly pays for itself dozens of times over.

For Budget-Conscious Casual Users (5% of users): Consider Willow Voice only if:

• You dictate less than 2 hours monthly

• Accuracy doesn't matter for your use case

• You use only basic text editors

• $10/month genuinely breaks your budget

• You're testing voice input for the first time

Even then, starting with Speechly's free trial makes more sense—why settle for inferior tools when you can test the best for free?

Take Action Today

Don't choose based on price alone—choose based on value and ROI.

Start Your Speechly Free Trial - No Credit Card Required →

Use it for 3 days. If it doesn't dramatically reduce your correction time and save you hours weekly, we'll be genuinely shocked.

1,200+ professionals didn't choose Speechly because it's cheaper (it's not). They chose it because the productivity gains are impossible to ignore once experienced.

Related Articles

• Best Speech-to-Text Apps for Mac in 2025 (Tested & Ranked)

• Speechly vs Wispr Flow: Complete Comparison for Mac Users

• Speechly vs Superwhisper: Which Mac Dictation Tool is Best?

• Dragon NaturallySpeaking Alternative for Mac: Complete Guide

• How to Dictate Emails 3X Faster on Mac

• Voice Typing for Sales Teams: Close More Deals Faster

About the Author

This comparison was conducted by the Speechly team with input from 150+ users who tested both tools extensively across real professional workflows. Our methodology prioritizes measurable productivity gains and ROI over marketing claims.

Last Updated: January 2025

Speechly is the Smart Speech-to-Text Co-Pilot for Mac trusted by 1,200+ professionals who demand the highest accuracy, reliability, and ROI. Try it free at speechly.io